Have a question?
Frequently Asked Questions
Please see below for answers to common questions from customers
General Information
Where is Blue Marlin Jewelry located?
You can visit us at two locations:
Islamorada Location
81549 Old Hwy
Islamorada, FL 33036-3607
(305) 664-8004
Key West Location
718 Caroline Street
Key West, FL 33040
(305) 517-6664
What are your store hours?
Both locations are open Monday through Saturday from 9:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. and Sunday from 11 a.m. to 5 p.m. Please call ahead to confirm holiday hours.
What types of jewelry do you carry?
Explore engagement rings, wedding bands, necklaces, bracelets, earrings, fashion rings, watches, and men’s jewelry. We also feature nautical designs and ancient and historical coin pieces.
Do you offer nautical jewelry?
Yes! Explore our nautical collection for jewelry that celebrates your connection to the ocean and the Florida Keys.
Do you sell engagement rings and wedding bands?
Yes. Browse our engagement rings, loose diamonds, and wedding bands to find a piece that celebrates your love story.
What makes Blue Marlin Jewelry unique?
As a family-owned jewelry store, we take pride in hand-selecting distinctive pieces from talented artists and designers. Our collections bring together fine jewelry, coastal inspiration, and individual style.
Is Blue Marlin Jewelry a member of the American Gem Society?
Yes. We are proud members of the American Gem Society, an organization dedicated to consumer protection, ethical business practices, and gemological knowledge.
Can I return a custom or personalized piece?
Custom, personalized, and special-order pieces are not eligible for returns. This also applies to items altered at your request, including resized rings and diamond upgrades. Please review our Return Policy before purchasing.
Jewelry Repairs & Services
Can you repair jewelry I purchased somewhere else?
Yes! We repair jewelry whether it was purchased from Blue Marlin Jewelry or another store. Bring your piece in for a free repair estimate.
Can you resize my ring?
Yes, we offer ring resizing. Bring your ring in so we can assess its design, metal, and settings to determine the best approach.
Can you fix a broken necklace or bracelet?
Yes. We offer chain repairs and clasp replacement to help you enjoy your favorite pieces again.
Can you replace a missing diamond or gemstone?
Yes, we offer stone replacement. Bring your jewelry in so we can evaluate the setting and discuss replacement options.
How much will my jewelry repair cost?
We offer free repair estimates. The cost depends on the condition of your jewelry, the materials, and the work needed.
Can you restore antique or heirloom jewelry?
Yes. We offer restoration for antique, heirloom, and estate jewelry, with attention to preserving each piece’s original character. Depending on its condition, restoration may include gemstone polishing, prong repairs, or resizing.
Do you repair watches?
Yes, we offer watch repairs. Contact us with your watch’s brand and the issue you’re experiencing so we can discuss your service needs.