Slide image


Cart 0

Congratulations! Your order qualifies for free shipping You are $200 away from free shipping.
Sorry, looks like we don't have enough of this product.

Is this a gift?
Subtotal Free
View cart
Shipping, taxes, and discount codes are calculated at checkout

Your Cart is Empty


Slide image

Custom Design

Create something that is entirely your own with custom jewelry design from Blue Marlin Jewelry. Whether you are dreaming of a one of a kind engagement ring, designing wedding bands, or transforming a meaningful piece of jewelry into something new, our team can help bring your ideas to life.

From the first conversation to the finished piece, we will work with you to understand your style, inspiration, and budget. Visit us in Islamorada or Key West to begin creating jewelry designed specifically for you.

From an Idea to Something Uniquely Yours

Custom jewelry gives you the freedom to create a piece that tells your story. Start with an inspiration, a favorite stone, an existing piece of jewelry, or simply an idea. Our team will help guide you through the possibilities and develop a design that feels personal to you.

Whether your style is timeless and traditional or modern and unexpected, every detail can be considered along the way.

The Custom Design Process

Step 1

Share Your Vision

Tell us what you have in mind. Bring photos, sketches, inspiration, an existing piece of jewelry, or simply describe what you are looking for.

Step 2

Explore Your Options

We will help you consider the details that bring your design together, including gemstones, diamonds, precious metals, setting styles, and other design elements.

Step 3

Review Your Design

Your concept begins to take shape as we refine the details and make sure the design reflects what you envisioned.

Step 4

Create Your Piece

Once the design is approved, your custom jewelry is carefully created and finished for you to enjoy for years to come.

Slide image

Create Your Engagement Ring

An engagement ring should feel as unique as the person wearing it. Custom design allows you to choose the details that matter most, from the center stone and setting to the metal, proportions, and finishing touches.

Already have an idea in mind? Let us help you turn it into a ring created specifically for your story. Still looking for inspiration? Explore our engagement ring collection to discover styles and details you love.

Slide image

Find the Perfect Wedding Bands

Your wedding bands are pieces you will wear every day and they should feel completely your own. Explore our collection of wedding bands or work with us to create a custom design that complements your engagement ring, personal style, or each other.

From classic bands to diamond styles and distinctive designs, we can help you find or create the rings that feel right for both of you.

Slide image

Reimagine Jewelry You Already Love

Custom design does not always have to begin from scratch.

A family diamond, inherited gemstone, or piece of jewelry you no longer wear can become the starting point for something entirely new. Our team can help you explore ways to incorporate meaningful elements into a new design while preserving the story behind them.

It is a beautiful way to honor the past while creating something that fits your life today.

Let’s Create Something Together

With locations in Islamorada and Key West, we are proud to help customers throughout the Florida Keys celebrate engagements, weddings, anniversaries, milestones, and everyday moments with jewelry created just for them.

Send Us A Message

Have an idea for a custom piece? We would love to hear about it. Tell us a little about what you are looking for below and select your preferred Blue Marlin Jewelry location. Our team will follow up to help you take the next step.

Fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required.